Between the Truths · 03
Christian Hardinghaus · October 2026
“He wants to tell us how to save money?” The line may get a laugh. It does not yet refute a calculation.
Imagine a public meeting. A resident proposes switching off a public building’s lights earlier. His calculation assumes 200 lamps drawing 10 watts each, operating for two fewer hours every evening. Someone responds not by challenging the figures, but by pointing out that the speaker has personal debts.
Invented example; it refers to no actual person.
A person is not a counterargument
The proposal contains a calculation we can check. Under its stated assumptions, the saving would be four kilowatt-hours per evening. Whether the change makes sense also depends on safety, building use and other costs. The speaker’s private debts answer none of those questions.
An ad hominem fallacy substitutes an attack on the person for a relevant response to the argument. Argumentation theory distinguishes different forms and examines their relevance in context. Douglas Walton devoted a book to analysing and evaluating such arguments. [1]
What would a relevant objection look like?
Someone might establish that the lamps draw a different amount of power. They might point out that the building is still in use at the proposed time. Perhaps the lighting already switches off automatically. These objections would address the proposal’s assumptions.
A mocking comment may also be hurtful. But the logical question is narrower: does the objection help us assess the claim? Politeness alone does not make an argument sound. Nor does a correct calculation become incorrect because we dislike its author.
When the source does matter
It would be equally mistaken to dismiss every criticism of a source as a distraction. When a claim depends on testimony, documented conflicts of interest, relevant expertise or demonstrated unreliability may matter. A useful objection explains specifically why this bears on the reliability of the claim in question.
That separates source evaluation from sweeping dismissal. “These measurements need independent checking because the sponsor benefits from the result” is different from “They were paid, so everything is made up.” Funding can warrant scrutiny. On its own, it establishes neither fraud nor the falsity of a particular finding.
Three questions to ask
- Which claim is the personal accusation supposed to refute?
- Is there a clear connection between the accusation and the reliability of that claim?
- Which evidence or reasons would I examine if someone else made the same argument?
Checking our own standards
The last question is especially useful when we already dislike a speaker. Would we accept the same calculation from a friend? Would we take a conflict of interest equally seriously if it affected our own side?
We do not have to admire somebody to acknowledge a valid point. Nor does trusting a person oblige us to accept every conclusion they reach. A useful debate makes room for both: scrutiny of sources and engagement with the arguments they actually make.
Explore the mechanism
Ad Hominem · Poisoning the Well
Sources
- Douglas Walton (1998): Ad Hominem Arguments. University of Alabama Press. Scholarly treatment of the forms and evaluation of arguments about a person. The examples and calculation in this article are original illustrations.
Examples without a source reference are original illustrations.

